2 Best Shopping in Long Island, New York

Captain Kid Toys

Even grown-ups will get sucked into this fun little shop. The harborside Captain Kid Toys brims with such fabulous toys, colorful trinkets, and artistic and educational kits, it's hard to say no.

484 W Lake Dr,, Montauk, New York, 11954, USA
631-668–4482

Stevenson's Toys and Games

Playing will make your kid smart, and with this in mind, Stevenson's—an old-fashioned toy shop—stocks educational toys designed to inspire the imagination and provide hours of fun. Madame Alexander dolls, Playmobil toys, stuffed animals, art-and-crafts supplies, and puzzles are among the selection of goods for the diminutive set. They have Halloween costumes too.