4 Best Restaurants in Searsport, Penobscot Bay

With tufted green leather settees and a wood-burning brick fireplace, the Homeport Tavern, part of the Homeport Inn, exudes an English-accented coziness. While bangers and mash and fish-and-chips give a nod to the old country and New England seafood is well represented, many dishes on the lunch and dinner menus have a distinctly Southern drawl. Items such as a shrimp po-boy, filé gumbo, smoked pork belly, and bread pudding with bourbon praline sauce hint at the chef's Louisiana roots. There's a good selection of Maine craft beers on tap.

This little restaurant has been around for a long time and has a large local following so it can be a little hard to get a table on a busy night, but it’s worth the wait. The traditional seafood dishes (fried or broiled) are good, the prices are reasonable, many dishes may be ordered in a "minnow" portion, and there are also a few choices for those who don't enjoy seafood.

Orange bar stools, dark walls with art deco--like horizontal stripes, and deep booths define this dimly lit "gastro dive bar" that lists cocktails under ports of call—Caribbean, New England, and the Pacific. The menu features tacos and a mostly Mexican-flavor selection of bar snacks, with a couple of dish detours to Thailand and the South. It's not what you'd expect in a small Maine seaport, and that adds to the fun.

Don't be put off by Rio's unlikely location in a small roadside strip of businesses just south of downtown Searsport. The well-prepared, European-influenced menu offers a variety of tapas such as grilled octopus, pâté, Spanish Serrano ham, and chorizo, as well as entrées like roasted branzino, risotto, and local duck breast. There's a solid cocktail menu and desserts are delicious, especially the panna cotta. Inside, a many-windowed octagonal dining room centers on a large fireplace, with tables arced around it.