6 Best Restaurants in Blue Hill, Blue Hill Peninsula

Arborvine

$$$ Fodor's choice

Glowing gas fireplaces, period antiques, exposed beams, and hardwood floors covered with Asian rugs make the the candlelit dining areas in this historic house elegant but homey. The menu features dishes made with such ingredients as carrots and apples from Horsepower Farm; mesclun from Carding Brook Farm in Brooklin; and mussels, scallops, and clams from Blue Hill Bay. 

33 Tenney Hill, Blue Hill, Maine, 04614, USA
207-374–2119
Known For
  • seasonal menus
  • fresh seafood dishes
  • farm-to-table ingredients
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: No lunch. Closed Sun.–Tues., Reservations required

Bucklyn Coffee

$ Fodor's choice

This tiny, friendly shop serves big, flavorful coffee and interesting sweet and savory pastries.

103 Main St., Blue Hill, Maine, USA
917-971–3246
Known For
  • Maine-roasted beans
  • coffee served anyway you like it
  • great place for a morning or early afternoon pick-me-up
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Barncastle Restaurant

$

Enjoy this inn restaurant's small-plate dishes, local beers, and craft cocktails in the quiet dining room or the rustic pub.

125 South St., Blue Hill, Maine, USA
207-374–2300
Known For
  • contemporary twists on comfort food classics
  • deck seating in nice weather
  • live music on weekends
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: No lunch

Sandy’s Blue Hill Café

$

Open for breakfast, lunch, and weekend brunch, this place has a mix of standard and surprising offerings, including a great falafel platter. If you want dinner, you can select from such house-made frozen dishes as beef stew, vegetable and cheese enchiladas, or Georgia onion pie. In summer, the café occasionally hosts special concert lunches and dinners (reservations required).

Siam Sky

$$

The long menu has all the Thai favorites (some of them gluten-free), from pad Thai and noodle soups to traditionally prepared seafood, chicken, beef, and duck entrées. Dine in the bright and airy dining room or out on the deck with its bright red chairs and umbrellas.